Meet the Commanders’ 2024 NFL Draft class: Grades for all 9 picks

Here we’ll look at the Washington Commanders’ 2024 NFL Draft class and provide our grades for all of their 9 draft picks.

Jayden Daniels, QB, LSU

Grade: A

The Commanders’ search for a quarterback to lead them at No. 2 overall in the 2024 NFL Draft culminated with the selection of Jayden Daniels. General Manager Adam Peters had zeroed in on Daniels weeks prior to the draft, diligently following through the evaluation process to ensure no last-minute concerns would alter their decision. Despite rumors of Daniels’ hesitancy towards joining the Commanders, he is eager to elevate this historic franchise. His dynamic and electrifying style of play promises to rejuvenate a fanbase that hasn’t seen such excitement since the days of Robert Griffin III. With hopes high, the coaching staff is poised to manage his talents wisely for sustained success. Daniels combines superb pocket awareness with his threat as a dual-threat quarterback, making him a formidable opponent and a thrilling addition under Kliff Kingsbury’s coaching.

Johnny Newton, DT, Illinois

Grade: A

Initially projected as a first-round pick, Johnny Newton’s formidable presence on the defensive line and his impactful play at Illinois made him a standout prospect. Yet, he surprisingly slipped beyond the first 32 picks. This scenario played into the Commanders’ hands perfectly as they contemplated trading up to secure him. With bated breath, they awaited their turn at No. 36, fortunate to find him still available. Newton is anticipated to be an immediate starter, adding significant strength to their defensive lineup.

Mike Sainristil, CB, Michigan

Grade: A

Endorsed as the top pound-for-pound player in the draft by none other than Nick Saban, Mike Sainristil’s exceptional play was instrumental in Michigan’s national championship success. General Manager Peters anticipates Sainristil will fill the STAR cornerback role, hinting at possible adjustments within Dan Quinn and Joe Whitt Jr.’s defensive strategy, such as shifting Quan Martin to a different position. Sainristil’s readiness and versatility are expected to make him an asset from the start.

Ben Sinnott, TE, Kansas State

Grade: A

Ben Sinnott’s draft stock soared following an impressive performance at the NFL Scouting Combine. His athleticism caught everyone’s attention, and further review of his play with Kansas State suggested he could be the next breakout star at tight end. Sinnott’s potential impact in the NFL appears promising, drawing attention to his broad skill set and adaptability.

Brandon Coleman, OL, TCU

Grade: B

Brandon Coleman stands out for his exceptional athletic abilities and his standout pass protection skills developed during his tenure at TCU. His technique and agility are top-notch, though his slightly shorter reach suggests he might fit better inside. Coleman’s intelligent play and robust build position him as a significant addition to the offensive line.

Luke McCaffrey, WR, Rice

Grade: B

Luke McCaffrey comes from a family of NFL stars. Sure, the expectations are high. However, his capabilities suggest he can forge a notable career in the league. Although further development and refinement are needed, McCaffrey’s foundational skills and family legacy provide a strong platform for success.

Jordan Magee, LB, Temple

Grade: B

Jordan Magee might not be the most physically imposing linebacker, but his speed and instincts compensate for any physical limitations. Magee’s ability to quickly diagnose plays and his improved coverage skills showcased last season at Temple justify his selection. However, some enhancement in his tackling technique remains necessary.

Dominique Hampton, S, Washington

Grade: B

Dominique Hampton may lack some technical finesse, but his athletic potential is undeniable, making him a valuable Day 3 pick. His versatility in the secondary aligns well with the creative defensive schemes of Dan Quinn and Joe Whitt Jr., Hampton just provides flexibility and depth.

Javontae Jean-Baptiste, EDGE, Notre Dame

Grade: B

Javontae Jean-Baptiste’s athletic profile from Notre Dame fits the mold of players who have previously thrived under Quinn’s coaching. Sure, immediate significant playing time may be unrealistic. However, Jean-Baptiste’s physical attributes suggest he can develop into a key player in the defensive rotation.

Looking Ahead

In conclusion, the Washington Commanders’ 2024 NFL Draft class appears poised to make significant contributions across the board. They ended up with a strategic mix of high-ceiling talents like Jayden Daniels and solid, foundational players such as Johnny Newton and Ben Sinnott. As such, the team has skillfully addressed critical areas of need while infusing the roster with potential star power. As these young athletes develop and adapt to the NFL’s demands, the Commanders could see a substantial return on their investments. This draft could mark a turning point for the franchise. It sets the stage for a revitalized squad ready to challenge the norms of the NFC East and perhaps signal a new era of competitiveness and success for the storied team.