How Have the Milwaukee Brewers Stayed On Top of Their Game?

Overall, the Brewers’ success may hinge upon the offenses’ stability as the season progresses. In recent seasons, the club could withstand bouts of offensive lethargy thanks to their outstanding pitching staff. However, they’re still adapting to an entirely new starting rotation, and the offense must continue to produce if the Brewers wish to hang around the top of the National League.

2. The Starting Rotation Has Stayed Afloat

As was just alluded to, Milwaukee’s starting rotation hasn’t been as dominant as fans have been accustomed to seeing. Yet, they have found a way to get the job done thus far despite the heavy turnover in the rotation.

They entered the 2024 season down three key long-time starters in Burnes (traded to the Baltimore Orioles), Adrian Houser (traded to the New York Mets), and Woodruff (season-ending shoulder surgery), and they’ve managed to compete despite the rotation looking so much different from a season ago.

Even further, since the season began, Wade Miley hit the shelf with a tear in his UCL that will require season-ending Tommy John surgery, Jakob Junis only made one start with his new club before hitting the injured list with a shoulder injury, and newcomer DL Hall struggled mightily to start the season prior to hitting the injured list with a knee sprain.

Yet, considering all that turnover amongst their starters, the Brewers have leaned into the “next man up” mentality, and it has helped them win ballgames.

In a pivotal year for Freddy Peralta‘s player development, he has evolved into an ace for the Milwaukee Brewers through the first month of the season. Opposing batters are hitting just .170 against him. In turn, he is rocking a WHIP of 0.98, which is seventh in the NL among qualified starters.

Beyond Peralta are a handful of starters who might not have the same level of name recognition, but they give the club a chance to win each time they take the mound.

Colin Rea continues to out perform his expected statistics and has been an extremely valuable arm for Milwaukee. The Brewers know what they’re getting out of him every time he toes the rubber, and that stability has been massive for this starting rotation.

Rea is 3-0 to start the year with a 2.67 ERA and a 1.22 WHIP. As mentioned, his peripheral metrics aren’t as encouraging (5.74 xERA, 4.77 FIP, 4.57 xFIP), but he has gone at least five innings in each of his six starts, and that has been extremely valuable for Milwaukee. His ability to pitch to soft contact and lean on the strong defense behind him will be a formula Rea will continue to utilize all season long.

Veteran newcomer Joe Ross is second among starters in fWAR (0.4), and it feels as if he has pitched better than his 4.65 ERA would indicate. Ross has done a good job at limiting hard contact, and is generating ground balls at an above average rate of 45.5%. In turn, he has an expected ERA of 3.90, a FIP of 3.92, and an xFIP of 4.41 through his first six starts.

Ross now has an important role in the middle of the rotation, and his offseason signing is proving to be mightily important for Milwaukee.

Bryse Wilson has been spectacular for the Brewers working as a swingman this season, and he is a big reason why the Brewers are in the position that they’re in. He has answered the call since transitioning from the bullpen to the starting rotation, providing the Brewers with efficiency and length in his first few turns through the rotation.

Across three starts, Wilson has a 1.93 ERA with an opposing batting average of just .184. He’s pitching to soft contact, as is illustrated by his 34.4% hard hit rate, and his most recent start was his best outing of the year, in which he went six inning of one run ball while only allowing four hits against the Tampa Bay Rays.

There’s a long way to go in the season, but the starting rotation has stayed afloat thus for the Brewers. This is an area on the roster where they could certainly look to add reinforcements, and they will need to get more length out of their starers as the season progresses in order to compete for a division title. That being said, it’s hard not to be impressed with what the group has done through the club’s first 32 games of the season.

3. Rock-Solid Bullpen

As mentioned, Milwaukee’s starters have struggled with stretching out ballgames in the early goings of the season, and the Brewers’ bullpen deserves a lot of credit for picking up the slack in that area. Their overall metrics may not fly off the page, but their performance is a big reason why the club is in the position that they’re in today.

Milwaukee’s bullpen has been about average when compared to the rest of the league. They’re 12th in ERA (3.61), 19th in FIP (4.10), and 15th in WHIP (1.25). Moreover, they’re 11th in baseball in fWAR (1.0), but they rank third in MLB in Win Probably Added (3.01). Each of their relievers has an important role in the bullpen, and they’ve heavily leaned upon their deep group of relievers in the early goings of the 2024 season.

In the absence of All-Star closer Devin Williams, the Brewers have utilized several different arms to fill the closer role. Five different pitchers have recorded a save for the Crew, with Joel Payamps leading the way with four of them.

On top of Payamps successfully filling the closer role for the Brewers, there have been a handful of standout performers through the first month of the season who have played a big role in the club’s success.

Perhaps the biggest story thus far has been newcomer Bryan Hudson, who has pitched to a 0.93 ERA across 19.1 innings of work. Acquired from the Los Angeles Dodgers this offseason, Hudson has been a pleasant surprise and a key lefty out of the bullpen this season.

Southpaw Hoby Milner continues to hold an extremely valuable role for the Brewers and has settled down after a bumpy start to the year, Elvis Peguero is building upon his breakout 2023 campaign and is one of the Brewers top setup options, and Trevor Megill has emerged as an essential arm and has the stuff to be a devastating closer in Williams’ absence.

All in all, as was the case in 2023, Milwaukee’s bullpen has played an essential role in the club’s hot start. If the Brewers wish to defend their division crown, they’re going to rely upon this group to get the job done.

Final Thoughts

The Milwaukee Brewers have been one of baseball’s best regular season performers in recent years. Their impressive ability to get the most out of players all throughout their roster has been a key factor in the club’s ability to consistency churn out wins, and that has continued to be the case this season.

Many expected the Brewers to take a major step back this season. Having lost so many key names in the starting rotation heading into Opening Day, it felt like 2024 was going to be a transition year for the Brewers as a new regime starts in Milwaukee.

While it is still plenty of baseball left to play, the Milwaukee Brewers have been one of the baseball’s biggest surprises to open the season. With a slight step back in the rotation came a major leap forward in their offensive production, and the Brewers appear primed to defend their division title.